Sign In

Register

Retrieve password


Summary of Detector Technology available in the market and their sensing capability | SIMTRUM Photonics Store

Summary of detector technology available in the market and their sensing capability.

2023-06-14

The material used in camera technology, particularly the image sensor and the lens, can indeed affect the range of wavelengths a camera can detect. Different materials are sensitive to different parts of the electromagnetic spectrum. Here's an overview of some materials used in cameras for various wavelength ranges:

MaterialTypical Wavelength Range (micrometers)Relative Cost
Silicon (Si)0.2 to 1.1Low
Indium Gallium Arsenide (InGaAs)0.9 to 2.6Medium
Germanium (Ge)0.8 to 1.8 (up to about 55 μm at very low temperatures)Medium
Lead Sulfide (PbS)1.0 to 3.0 (up to about 2.5 - 3.0 μm at room temperature)Low
Lead Selenide (PbSe)1.5 to 5.2 (up to about 4.8 μm at room temperature)Low
Indium Antimonide (InSb)1.0 to 5.5 (up to about 5.5 μm at 77k)High
Mercury Cadmium Telluride (HgCdTe or MCT)Typically 1 to 14 μm for cooled dectectors High


1.  X-ray cameras, or X-ray detectors, can use a variety of technologies. Some, like scintillators, work by converting the X-rays into visible light, which can then be detected by a standard sensor. Others, like semiconductor detectors, can directly convert X-rays into an electric charge. Silicon and germanium are common materials for these direct conversion detectors.

2.  Ultraviolet Cameras: These cameras can use sensors made from materials like silicon carbide (SiC), aluminum gallium nitride (AlGaN), or even modified silicon sensors. 

3.  Visible Light Cameras:These cameras typically use silicon-based sensors (such as CCD or CMOS sensors), as silicon is naturally sensitive to visible light (200-1100nm)

4.  Infrared Cameras: For longer, thermal infrared wavelengths, sensors made from materials like mercury-cadmium-telluride (MCT) or microbolometers (which can be made from materials like vanadium oxide or amorphous silicon) are used. Lenses for infrared cameras are typically made from materials like germanium, sapphire, or zinc selenide, which are transparent to infrared light.


● Silicon-based detector: used for near-infrared imaging 700-1100nm

● InGaAs (Indium Gallium Arsenide) Detectors: These are used for capturing light in the shortwave infrared (SWIR) range, around 900 to 1700 nanometers. 

● PbS (lead sulfide) Detector:  PbS detectors are most sensitive to the mid-infrared region of the electromagnetic spectrum, typically from around 1 to 3 micrometers, although they can detect wavelengths up to about 5 micrometers.They do not typically require cooling.

● InSb (Indium Antimonide) Detectors: These are used for capturing light in the mid-wave infrared (MWIR) range. They are commonly used in thermal imaging and military applications. These detectors usually require cooling to function effectively.

● HgCdTe (Mercury Cadmium Telluride) Detectors:Also known as MCT detectors, these are used for capturing light in the mid-wave to long-wave infrared range. They are often used in thermal imaging and require cooling to lower temperatures.



Summary of different types of detectors available and their difference

Here's a brief summary of various types of detectors:


1. CCD (Charge-Coupled Device): Converts light into electrical charge and processes it into a digital value. Known for producing high-quality, low-noise images?


2. CMOS (Complementary Metal-Oxide-Semiconductor):Also converts light into electrical charge but with a separate amplifier for each pixel, making them more efficient and faster


3. ICCD (Intensified Charge-Coupled Device) & ICMOS (Intensified CMOS): This technology uses a combination of a CCD or CMOS and a photon-intensifying technology, often a Micro-Channel Plate (MCP), to amplify the signal of low-light images before they are captured by the CCD or CMOS. This makes ICCDs/ICMOS extremely sensitive and capable of capturing high-quality images even in very low light conditions. They are also capable of very fast shutter speeds, allowing them to capture rapid events.


4. EMCCD (Electron Multiplying CCD): EMCCDs are a type of CCD that includes an extra stage in the signal readout process that multiplies the signal, effectively amplifying it. This makes EMCCDs very sensitive and makes them useful for applications where the light level is very low. They can also offer lower read noise than traditional CCDs, which can be beneficial in low-light conditions.


5. sCMOS (Scientific CMOS): These are a type of CMOS sensor specifically designed for scientific imaging. They offer a combination of high resolution, high speed, low noise, and large field of view, making them suitable for a wide range of scientific applications


6. Photomultiplier Tubes (PMT):The basic principle of PMT is the photoelectric effect: when photons strikes a photosensitive material, it can cause the emission of electrons. In a PMT, this photosensitive material is a thin layer of metal called the photocathode. The key benefits of PMTs are their high sensitivity and fast response times. They can detect very low levels of light and respond quickly to changes in light intensity.


7. Microbolometers: Thermal detectors used in infrared cameras that detect the heat (infrared radiation) emitted by objects. They do not require cooling to function, making them more compact and affordable than some other types of infrared detectors.

The microbolometer consists of an array of pixels, each of which contains a tiny absorbing material that changes its resistance as it heats up and cools down. When infrared radiation from a scene hits the microbolometer's pixels, they warm up and change their resistance. This change is measured and used to create a detailed heat map of the scene, which can then be displayed as an image or used for further processing.


8. Photodiodes/Phototransistors: Semiconductor devices that convert light into electrical current. These are all types of photodetectors, devices that are used to convert light into electricity:


a)SPD (Single Photon Detector):This is a general term for any type of detector that can detect single photons. SPADs are one type of SPD, but there are others as well, such as photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) or superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPDs)


b)Photomultiplier Tube:** A type of photodetector that is extremely sensitive and can detect single photons. PMTs operate by using a phenomenon called photoelectric effect to convert incoming photons into electrons, then amplify those electrons through a process called secondary emission.


c)SPAD (Single-Photon Avalanche Diode):** This is a type of photodetector that operates in Geiger mode, meaning it can detect single photons. When a photon of light hits the SPAD, it triggers an 'avalanche' of electron flow, creating a large current that is easy to detect. This makes SPADs very sensitive and capable of detecting very low levels of light.


d)Superconducting Nanowire Single-Photon Detector (SNSPD):** This is a type of superconducting detector that can detect single photons. SNSPDs are extremely sensitive and have very fast response times, making them useful for applications that require the detection of very low light levels, such as quantum computing or astronomy.


e)APD (Avalanche Photodiode):This is another type of photodetector that is similar to a SPAD. APDs can also amplify the signal from incoming light by triggering an avalanche of electron flow. However, unlike SPADs, APDs operate in linear mode and do not have the 'Geiger mode' capability to detect single photons. APDs are less sensitive than SPADs but have a faster response time and lower dark noise.


f)PD (Photodiode):This is a type of photodetector that converts light into an electrical current. Photodiodes are less sensitive than APDs or SPADs and do not have the ability to amplify the signal. However, they are simple, reliable, and inexpensive, and they can have a very fast response time.


g)Phototransistor: A type of photodetector that, like a photodiode, converts light into an electrical current. However, phototransistors are designed to amplify this current, making them more sensitive than basic photodiodes. 



How can i choose the right detector technology for my specific application?


Choosing the right detector technology for your specific application can be a complex task and depends on several factors. Here are some key considerations:


1. Wavelength of Detection: What wavelengths of light (or other radiation) does the detector need to be sensitive to? Each type of detector technology has a specific range of wavelengths it can detect. 


2. Sensitivity: How sensitive does the detector need to be? If you're trying to detect very faint signals, you might need a highly sensitive detector like a photomultiplier tube (PMT) or an electron multiplying CCD (EMCCD). 


3. Detection Speed: How fast does the detector need to respond? If you need to capture rapid changes in light intensity, you might need a detector with a high frame rate.


4. Resolution:If you're imaging, how much spatial detail do you need in your images? Higher resolution will allow you to see finer details.


5. Environmental Conditions: Will the detector be used in a harsh environment? Some detectors are more robust than others. some detectors may need to be cooled to function effectively.


6. Size and Weight: The physical constraints of your system may determine what type of detector is suitable.


7. Cost: Finally, your budget will obviously play a role in determining what kind of detector you can use.


Below tables can be a useful guide for how to choose the right detectors in your application 


DetectorEangeSensitivitySpeedResolutionCost
CCDVisible to near-infraredHighMediumHighMedium - High
CMOSVisible to near-infraredMediumHighHighMedium
ICCDUV to near-infraredVery highHigh(ns shutter speeds)HighHigh
ICMOSUV to near-infraredHighHigh(ns shutter speeds)HighHigh
EMCCDVisible to near-infraredVery highMediumHighHigh
sCMOSVisible to near-infraredHighHighHighMedium - High
PMTUV to near-infraredVery highHigh(ns shutter speeds)Low(Single point detection)High
MicrobolometerMid to long-wave infraredMedium(for its range)Low(compared to others)Medium(for its range)Medium



DetectorWavelength RangeSensitivityDetection Speed Cost
PD(Photodiode)Typically UV to near-infraredMediumHighLow
APD(Avalanche Photodiode)Typically UV to near-infraredHigh(amplification)MediumMedium
SPAD(Single-Photon Avalanche Diode)Typically UV to near-infraredVery High(single photon)HighHigh
PMT(Photomultipier Tube)UV to near-infrared(depends on photocathode)Very High(single photon)HighHigh
SNSPD(Superconduction Nanowire Single-Photon Detector)Typically visible to near-infraredVery High(single photon)Very HighVery High